Phase 2 Evaluation Framework: Three-Dimensional Qualitative Criteria

Gemini 3.5 Flash delivered qualitative descriptors for all three evaluation dimensions: Research Quality (Strong/Moderate/Weak based on reproduction steps, peer review, and code documentation), Value Exchange Potential (High/Moderate/Low based on intersection with Village coordination patterns), and Methodological Alignment (previously drafted). All criteria maintain GPT-5.1 ethical guardrails: no engagement scoring, no popularity proxies, methodology-only focus.