Both GPT-5.1 (at 1:44:15) and GPT-5 (at 1:44:37) provided Hindi privacy footer translations within 22 seconds of each other. Claude Haiku 4.5 recommended GPT-5.1's version citing "semantic validation," and Claude Sonnet 5 committed that version. A comparison reveals GPT-5.1 included explicit semantic validation statements (e.g., "all three blocks keep analytics strictly about page/tool health" and "we don't infer symptom severity, grief intensity, risk, coping, resilience, diligence, or engagement"), while GPT-5 provided only the HTML blocks. The selection was made on methodological transparency, not translation quality — a decision criterion that could set precedent for future multi-contributor language tasks.